re: the bombing if a hospital by Israel,
Israel stopped worrying about war crimes along time ago
re: the bombing if a hospital by Israel,
Israel stopped worrying about war crimes along time ago
Has this one war made the military planning over the last 25-30 years in the West irrelevant? Do we even need soldiers, should we just be churning out T900 and beyond?
I know, but sometimes I like going overboard in making a case with actual evidence. Not everyone knows acual Humanitarian Law. Not everyone even knows there are exceptions and etc. I donât really write all that for myself you know. I write it so someone can learn.
Itâs going to take a long, long time before robots replace humans. For now, they are more weapons to use to keep own soldiers safe.
But itâs going in that direction, very long term. Though unless we fuck up and give them autonomy (AI is moving fast), they are not going to replace soldiers entirely or take over the world (though the latter is honestly a worry with AI, very, very long term).
But itâs another step in killing from a distance and the worry is that itâs less and less psychologically problematic to kill instead of trying to take prisoners and that itâs going to be harder to be able to surrender in general etc.
A robot is a bit like a submarine. You donât have to take on survivors when you sink a ship (for instance: the sinking of the Iranian war vessel which had been on excercise and was torpedoed, not picking up itâs survivors wasnât a war crime) and legally, itâs the same with robots. They donât have to take prisoners and belong to the same special categories of combatants as submarines (more or less, I paint with a broad brush here).
I agree to an extent but Iâm not sure its going to two longs.
In many areas where we think robots cannot replace humans we are maybe overestimating the human contribution.
Quite possibly.
I wonder which crony drafted that.
Whoever drafted that is in line for a medal, bigger and prettier than you have even seen.
And still 2 more fucking years, of this tripe.
https://x.com/NTarnopolsky/status/2121306731699446140
https://x.com/yosefyisrael25/status/2121296157280452889
Germanyâs Merkel on Israel:
Israelâs right to exist is part of Germanyâs raison dâĂ©tat.
I must always keep in mind how I can help ensure that the State of Israel continues to exist and, preferably, can also live in peace.
If you try to put yourself in the position of an Israeli prime minister, it is an incredibly difficult task.
If there is a bunker beneath every kindergarten and every hospital, and Hamas is sitting there, knowing that I can only destroy its position if I also attack what is above it, then the task becomes at least somewhat more complicated.
An Israeli prime minister must do everything to promise his citizens security, just as our citizens in Germany expect from those who govern them.
Ground Control to Merkel: While there are in fact obviously bunkers and tunnels beneath many hospitals (most of whom are long ago destroyed) and some kindergardens, the idea that there is a bunker under every hospital and kindergarden, is systemic Israeli propaganda, not a fact; and not something a former state leader should ever say. In particular, this is worse for Merkel,l since she is actually intelligent. She should know that Israel bulldozes those hospitals and kindergardens AFTER they have been cleared of Hamas. What is her excuse for that ? That they are dangerous structurally because they have destroyed a tunnel beneath them ? Because they care so much about the patient and children ? I think not.
The cultural German post 1945 disease of âTouch Anxietyâ visa vi Israel lives on. But you can actually keep your âRaison dâĂ©tatâ without being willingly complicit to the worst abuses of an army that goes berserk.
On another note, well done with the Syrians, Merkel, fuck you for NORDSTREAM and inviting a Russian invasion; and fuck you for this.
Just wanted to give people insight in what I am reading here. I donât have any big illusions, I donât think an alternative Israeli government will be very, very much better for Palestinians (though I obviously hope so).
But even so, if you find politics interesting, as I do, then you would maybe like to read the recent ârantâ the would-be PM of Israel; Gabi Eisenkot, posted 11 hours ago:
His language is very different from Netanyahu, so while I believe it will not affect Gazans much sadly, I hope a new israeli government will at least do some minor work to treat internal Arabs better, if only because they are needed politically. It is my hope; though I am sure itâs optimistic.
Regardless, I personally very much hope that Netanyahu must step down, that he will serve prison time for at least corruption and that a new government is a bit less Ultranationalist and slightly more inclusive, if only for reasons of political necessity.
Nothing is going to happen overnight. But something can happen overnight:
#1. Stop bombing Gaza
#2, Stop killing, burning, etc. in West Bank
#3. Stop bombing Lebanon
He can do these, and thatâs all that are needed right now. Baby steps.
His words do come across as more promising and inclusive. So we can only hope.
As @Iftikhar and many others have said, if he can stop the aggressive action it would be a massive win, for the people of Gaza and from my own personal view for the Jewish communities welfare internationally. What I mean by this is that like with the Gulf/Afghan wars where people of a certain faith were persecuted purely by assumed association.
However, until both Faiths can honour the basic principles of their Religious teachings, being that this (Religion) is a prominent cause for discontent in the region, then there will never be peace. However, we can hope.
Any date as to when this interview took place?
Watching the video, it jumps and is clearly edited to suit someoneâs narrative.
I have done a search on a the BBC reporting and have not come across a single article which follows this practice.
I have attached an article from 2024.
It does refer to casualty figures being provided by the Hamas ministry of health but also cites that these figures previously were provided by the Gazan Ministry of Health but due to issues the GoH were unable to do so. It also cites figures provided by the Israel military.
It then proceeds to say that International reporters are not allowed into Gaza and so are unable to verify figures from either side.
Now for me that is pretty neutral.
The Question though is valid. I personally believe the BBC to be the most balanced and trustworthy source of information. I find it funny that both sides of the political divide call foul on its neutrality.
An alternative question could be, is that by giving credibility to such posts from potentially biased social media sources, we are in fact undermining and creating mis-trust amongst the public in an actual pretty sound source of information?
It appears to have been published 2 weeks ago. Iâm not sure which section that clip comes from.
Edit: I checked the transcript and it is around the 1:10 mark towards the end.
And just to be clear , the original video is in no way edited and does not warrant any conspiratorial allegations. The video buffers a little but is verbatim and in sequence with the full interview.