The Middle East Thread

https://x.com/academic_la/status/1795126945229029587

1 Like

https://x.com/Faytuks/status/1795111386680291647
Yes, yes. We have heard IDF already stating that there was supposed to be no civilian casualties. And the two Hamas targets being located in an IDP camp, a tent camp, did not ring any bells, did it ? Of course not. I am sure there are many in the IDF and the political leadership that is against such targets being hit (we know they have strong heated disagreements regarding how much Civ Cas should be acceptable in a strike from before), but many in the IDF and the political leadership is in favour; so…
But since this is so high profile, maybe, maybe, eventually, it might contibute to changing something. But probably not now, and certainly not alone.

Yesterday it was this though:

It’s like watching the mini Kremlin inventing competing theories, while at the same time justifying it in propaganda (not that the Kremlin has ever admitted a single mistake in it’s war in Ukraine, but then again, they don’t have the US as Sugar Daddy that they have to some how please either).

2 Likes

https://x.com/haaretzcom/status/1795111468171673858

Meanwhile:
https://x.com/skotrds/status/1795041049800269872
https://x.com/skotrds/status/1795042301309329473

If Erdogan is serious, Turkey can do a lot unofficially and they have a very extensive history using Jihadists as pawns in the last 2 decades. Al Qaida, ISIS, they use it all if it suits them in their geoplitical goals.

But I am on the fence about Erdogan being serious.

All day, I tried to make sense of this atrocity. I concluded that ICC charges couldn’t come soon enough.

4 Likes

Imo, from my perspective, I don’t think Israeli political leadership is in complete control over all elements of the IDF and I also think the IDF is split. Much like a…millitia. I think there is a good chance that the person giving strike intel lies or omitts information and/or the one who takes the decision to strike just ignores RoE from political leadership. That would not be strange, since half the political leadership supports this while the other half sees it as very unfortunate.
I think this war has proved, with all the countless videos from IDF soldiers uploading various smaller types of war crimes or bad behaviour such as wanton destruction of property and making it into a joke and more(but that together becomes very, very big crimes); well I think it has proved that the IDF severely lacks dicipline and coherency. They may fight well, but they behave like a horde in areas they take in Gaza.

2 Likes

In what appears to be a burnt-out building in Gaza, with Hebrew graffiti on the walls reading “Kach” and “Kahane”, references to an infamous Jewish supremacist and his outlawed political party, a masked soldier addresses Israel’s defence minister.

“Yoav Gallant, you can’t win the war. Quit. You can’t command us,” the man says in a long clip posted to social media on Saturday, in which he pledges loyalty to the prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu. Another 100,000 reservists would mutiny, he warned, if wavering elements of the government such as Gallant scuppered Netanyahu’s goal of “complete victory” over Hamas.

The above is from a Guardian article published today. But I heard similar things for weeks in not-so-mainstream media.

1 Like

Yeah, I know…
It’s not…good. There are so many extremists in their army, many from the Settler movement and etc.

1 Like

Worth a watch

1 Like

https://x.com/spectatorindex/status/1795036134327669158

1 Like

Its because Hamas fired missiles into Tel Aviv earlier in the day.

2 Likes

Do we think Turkey might get involved?

Either by increasing tangential involvement, or more overtly?

It must be difficult, with their military resources, to watch the IDF act so brutally.

1 Like

Turkey will not get directly involved. Turkey if it gets involved will use jihadists and a few specialists under cover from their mil intelligence. That is how Turkey controls most of northern Syria.

4 Likes

Further escalation worries me, that Israel continue until it prompts extreme retaliatory measures from the Arab world.

2 Likes

And then goes running to America for help, playing the victim.

2 Likes

I dont think so, US are turned away from them, I fear even worse than that. Israel will take unmitigated action at Iran.

Meanwhile, according to some sources, Egypt continues to slowly mobilise it’s two primary Field Armies (this has supposedly been going on for many months). They have 3-4 divisions in Sinai now, one of which is at Rafaf.

(I am not saying that I think that Egypt is planning to attack israel, I don’t).

1 Like

Well if you know Israel do. Was about to say the mobilisation could exert influence, then seemingly not.

Israel is busy preparing to invade Lebanon at the political cabinet’s decision and doesn’t take Egypt seriously.