UK Politics Thread - read the rules before posting!

2 Likes

I would be surprised if anything much more than a customs union was going to be possible any time soon. The freedom of movement thing would presumably be a big problem politically for the government to sell to voters.

1 Like

It would presumably solve the problem with low value shipments (TEMU tax). I’ve had a couple of magazines cancel future subscriptions because of that recently.

1 Like

That’s what the studies show. I’m not saying just allow people to commit fraud when it becomes known, but at the level it’s thought to happen, the kind of money and effort it would take to root out becomes counter productive.

1 Like

It’s actually one of the things that the ID cards were meant to clamp down on. A lot of fraud comes down to identity theft.

2 Likes

@Rambler The report refrenced in this article estimates Ā£3.6b in lost tax revenue from ā€˜cash in hand’ practices

Cash-in-hand economy contributes to billions in unpaid UK tax | Media Centre | Loughborough University

1 Like

Id cards themselves have to be open to fraud. Let alone the hullabaloo over privacy.

But you look at the cost of the state now and have to question value for money. Ok. Back to death bed.

7. Tax gaps: Illustrative tax gap by behaviour - GOV.UK

The estimated Tax Gap in 2024-2025 was £59.2b or 6.2% total theoretical tax liabilities.
1. Tax gaps: Summary - GOV.UK

That’s a lotta money.

1 Like

Person working gets paid cash in hand > also claims UC/Housing Benefit > Claims PIP > sells drugs > pays no council tax > pays no or vey little water > pays no tv licence > uses food banks > claims grants > claims eligibility for free white goods/furniture.

It is short sighted to look at just one cost to the tax payer.

1 Like

I think and i am not 100% certain, that i understand the thieving common man and the system , whilst many understand the politics and the numbers.

I am not saying it is this govt or that govt. Politicians don’t see it for themselves because they don’t live amongst it , they don’t have or have had friends that garner the system.

This from official gov stats. OK so maybe only 6.5 new hospitals :wink:

(FYE 2025) Context

Total Overpayments:Ā£9.5 billion (3.3% of benefit expenditure)
Fraud portion: £6.5 billion
Claimant Error:Ā£1.9 billion
Official Error: £1.0 billion

1 Like

Just an example.

Enjoying watching Andy ā€œhopeā€ Burnham. Sorry. Back to bed.

Politicians, especially those on the right frequently rail against benefit fraud, real or imagined, and we’ve had successive governments looking for any opportunity to reduce welfare spending - such that it is hard to imagine that they would purposely ignore it or that government departments (and their ministers) be unaware of fraud risks.

2 Likes

That’s the huge issue. Political class do not care about the country. They care about elections. Whether it’s Burnham (corrupt lol ) Kemi. The issue is the election cycle. PR will not fix it. I have to say conservative / Lib Dem coalition was the better balance.

Ok bed.

1 Like

The conservatives created the issue. So they should know all the issues with the system. The perceived far right jump on the mood of the nation, so a lot of talk from people suspecting benefit fraud, gives them a bandwagon.
Labour need to do something about it. If one doesn’t live amongst it and see it daily then one can ignore it as just a statistic.
They ignore it as much as possible because one doesn’t want to been seen as picking on disabled people, people like me.
Numbers might stay the same in terms of spend but if it is going to the right people and putting food on the plates of children then i ll take a short term hit for the greater good, personally.

No. Conservatives caused it? Come on. My point was political class. Labour. Right. It’s a different world. That will change nothing. Give me a few years of Reform to just change the system.

1 Like

Which ever way you cut it this discussion is showing there’s a whole lot of wasted and unrealised money out there. If the Tax gap is Ā£60b and the wellfare over-spend is Ā£10b it’s pretty reasonable to expect a whole lot of other fuck ups, so maybe Ā£100b of extra beans out there. If only half of that could be saved/collected, it would make a huge difference.

2 Likes

Can’t watch but is it saying that on average each of them got 2mp a year from benefit fraud?

I don’t think they will change it for the better. They seem to have some madcap ideas. sacking people after 100 days and putting the military in the sea to stop migrants ( seems like an ideal attack point for extremists). I don’t know anything about what they would do to fix debt etc.