UK Politics Thread - read the rules before posting!

And there you have it. Rich people. Many of the parents who send their children to the school my daughter goes to scrimp and save to give their child a better education. They do not go on holiday. They live in a semi. Rich? No.

Vat on school fees made no difference to parents who’s kids go to Eton. It hurt ordinary people badly. Pushed more kids into state school. Closed schools and lost jobs.

Rich people do not pay as much tax. Do you know how percentages work? It’s the same old argument.

Respectfully I won’t cry you a river. You clearly have a view. Which is fine. But it’s blinkered and a bit binary. Thats the issue with politics. Left see money as bad. Right see wealth distribution as bad. Black and white.

They said they do not expect to reduce welfare before the next election. Then they will do it in a “Labour way”.

And farmers are rich?

I wouldn’t say “ordinary” is the right choice of word here. Most of these parents are far from the poverty line and compared to the larger portion of people that are below their economic level, they are pretty well off. That is not to say they don’t work hard but ordinary - I’m not sure? The “ordinary” people will never be able to access private, fee paying schools, no matter how hard their parents work.

4 Likes

What is rich? 50k a year? 100k a year? Millions? Or just more than you earn?

“Pretty well off”. But they worked for it. They earn it. It’s not given to them.

Not cash rich, no.
Unfortunately the people who want their families taxed to the hilt with inheritance tax, probably also want home produced food.
Ironic short sightedness

This is an interesting question and one I’d pose to you.
I have read you proposing fixed rate income tax. Do you know how that would affect different wage groups?
From what I understand ‘private’ schools get an incredible amount of ‘government’ funding. I don’t see why those that ‘benefit’ from these schools shouldn’t give some back.
Scimping and saving to put a half decent meal on the table is much harder than that involving sending your kids to a school. I bet your examples of scimping and saving say the same about changing their cars every 5 years.

3 Likes

You see what you want to see. I can assure you they do not change cars.

Of course state funding. Of course they did not work for it. At some point you just come across as jealous that some people worked hard and did ok. Not well. Ok.

And not sure this would work. Just exploring ways to change the country and the economy.

I’m not allowed to be rich. over 16k in savings and the government will expect me to live on it until it is below the 16k. I guess i could pay into a pension fund but I’ll get screwed down the line for having a private pension and a state pension no doubt.
I can;t afford a smart asshole that can use all the legal financial loopholes. Some folk think they re poor on 50k a year as a single person… meanwhile 30 odd k a year including rent for a family of 5. I don’t know what is rich or what is poor.. but i know i can’t afford a decent sized jar of coffee.

1 Like

Admittedly, I have a big, and probably irrational, issue with private education. It seems to me the most overt way you can buy your kids an unfair advantage over other people’s kids.

It’s a bit silly, because there are obviously loads of ways that we all advantage our kids. But none are quite as effective as sending your kids to private school because you can, and some else can’t. So I can’t help it.

I try to exercise some sympathy with parents who find themselves on the fuzzy edge of the issue, where they are genuinely sacrificing to get their kids to private school. But I find it hard to do so, because when you dig into these stories, these sacrifices are so often things like holidays, new cars, meals out etc. When I think about people making sacrifices for their kids, I think about people skipping meals, wearing blankets because they can’t put the heating on, not having a holiday at all. It doesn’t compare. And what is the right wing rhetoric you hear when their stories make it to the media? Get a better job. Make saving elsewhere. It’s easy to live on 40p a day. You just have to make an effort (that’s Reform’s Lee Anderson).

And then you dig into what private education actually does to the country, and how many ills have been visited upon us by public school wankers. What’s the main benefit of a private education? Psychotic self-confidence, abandonment issues (for those that board), and an incredible network of contacts. Whenever I come across a privately educated person in my career or life I’m struck by how amazingly unbothered and unaffected they are by being totally wrong about stuff. How quickly they can bounce back from completely fucking everything up. And these people end up in Government or running everything.

So, no. I don’t like private education.

3 Likes

I think the farming inheritance tax is far more nuanced than putting VAT on private schools, and there are probably more cases of people struggling as a result.

However it is notable that the most prominent campaigner against the farm inheritance tax had previously boasted that he’d bought a farm to avoid paying tax.

2 Likes

Great reply. Thank-you. There is a million miles difference from me and others saving to put our kids in private school to Eaton and the rest. I agree the boys club of old school handshakes and networks has been ruinous. Most private schools are small and no where near Eton or Harrow.

When I thought I could put my daughter through private I visited some. I actually cried, My experience of a brutal Yorkshire comprehensive was so bad that seeing I could give my child the chance to avoid that was emotional. We all want the best for our kids.

I guess the real issue is state education and how bad that has become.

2 Likes

100% spot on.

I love Clarkson’s Farm. He admits he has money so does not need to make it from farming. But the effort and hard work to make next to nothing is brutal. Its a real insight into farming. Of course they have land and a value in that but its a hard game.

Buying a farm to avoid inheritance tax is an outlier. Many farms have been in the family for generations. We rely on them to feed the country.

I saw this article a few days ago and it left me in quiet dread. As some comentators take macabre joy at the turmoil in Europe, it may be worth considering that the core issue is the same everywhere in geographical Europe - the standard of living continues to trend down and the cost of living continues upward. In addition the generations being printed out now are from a factory that hasn’t been upgraded for more than half a century and therefore they are finding their opportunities limited and un-glorious (for those that dream).

The pressures that this will create socially will not be trivial.

and thats why we have riots in France and other places. Now Germany.

None of it is protest. It’s thuggery and looting.

I reckon we both experienced terrible Yorkshire comprehensive schools. I did OK. I got my GCSEs, and went on to A Levels and Uni. But I was maybe one of five out of more than a hundred that did? The teaching was sub-standard and half-arsed, and half of them were fucking perverts.

But it was also 35 years ago. A lot of my family still go to that school now, and it’s unrecognisable. The school my kids go to now has challenges, but it’s at least professional and competent, and despite the stuff they get wrong, it is at least set up in such a way that kids can suceed if they want to.

I know that there will be bad school outliers, but I just don’t buy the argument that state schooling is so uniformly bad that people are forced to go private. I understand that argument with the NHS, which is so on its fucking knees that I totally understand people taking that route out of desperation. I’m considering a private route for my son’s ADHD medication, aa our wait through the NHS now approaches a decade. I hate that. I hate that the NHS is pushing me into being a total bloody hypocrite. But I just don’t see those same pressures in education sector.

I read something above that caught my eye. If anyone knows, please weigh in.

Does public money help to subsidize private schools? Cheers.

We are about the same age. Yes school was brutal. I know that a couple of kids I went to school with are in prison for murder!

I did ok. Despite being bullied for trying. I got my O levels and A levels and went to Polytechnic. Since then I have done okay. Which puts me right in the cross hairs of the UK Politics thread!

Its a choice. 40 kids in a class or 12? The way I see it its not about my daughter being ahead of state school kids. Its about quality of life. Just not having the shit time I did. Being allowed to be curious and learn without being beaten for being “posh” or clever.

and sorry for your son. The NHS is on its knees. Despite the best efforts of the amazing people who work there. I have had private health through my work for years and its the most amazing thing. To get to see a specialist, get a scan etc when you need it, It’s not hypocrisy mate. Its doing the best for your kids,