UK Politics Thread - read the rules before posting!

Do not get me started. I am not sure any of them are intelligent.

1 Like

I don’t see the contradiction. You might need to explain to me why believing a higher education is a benefit is as odds with a left learning political belief.

2 Likes

I am coming to the view. Left leaning. Left wing. Has had its day. It’s not for modern UK. It’s the past. When we had nationalised industry. When big state was the answer.

It is not now. You can tax all you like. You can be jealous of anyone who makes money. You can run up debt as you always do. You can legislate business so much they do not hire.

The thing that’s wrong is no one stepped in. The Conservatives wasted years.

But the Labour Party will set the country back a decade. As they do every time.

1 Like

They want a large nanny state. They have missed every target they set. On house building. Migration. But Burnham has a good line in rhetoric.

Raynor has a good line of lies and hypocracy. It’s yesterdays politics. Welcome to the 70s.

Oh and this government is spiteful. See vat on school fees. Backfired. But let’s help every postcode be better. Especially Manchester and Abu Dhabi.

Rolling back to the 1970s is undoubtedly not the answer, and in that sense Labour really may need to make a different peace with the Blair legacy. However, rolling back to Thatcher’s deregulation is also fairly clearly not the answer, even if that was a necessary correction to what Britain circa 1978 was.

In economic terms, I think the pre-eminent public policy problem of the West today is concentration of capital. The UK has suffered that as acutely as anywhere, capital has been drained out of the productive economy and into the finance sector (as well as real estate), leading to a stalled productivity growth in the broader economy. Simply deregulating won’t fix that, it will more likely accelerate it. There is definitely some regulatory change required, but I really don’t believe it is universally in the simple direction of removing it. I don’t know if Piketty’s recommendations are ideal, but he is definitely reaching for something.

7 Likes

Really? Is that a view you are just coming to?

6 Likes

Tragic Irony….

People talk in absolutes about regulation way too much (not necessarily you). Some deregulation is good, some regulation is good.

For example deregulating in a way that stops blocking people from forming businesses or getting ideas off the ground is good.

Regulating more where corporations take advantage of public goods or businesses or people have externalities is also good.

2 Likes

I don’t think the argument (especially not mine) is that state schooling is uniformly bad. It is open to opinion but it didn’t do me no harm….
If people want to send their children to Private school they should be encouraged, not vilified or priced out of that option. They already pay taxes which contribute to the state and by going private, they surely remove a burden on the system both physically and financially, surely this should only be encouraged.
If someone believes they are putting their children at an advantage by working hard to pay for Private education then fair f**ks, but of course it is only billionaire, tax dodging, Tory voters that do that.
I am really sorry to hear about your issues with your Sons medication and the delays through the NHS. However, I am going to be straight up with you. If you are able to afford to pay for your son’s medication privately, then why are you even questioning this or considering yourself a hypocrite.
Sorry Son, I can’t help you because it is against my principles. I Cant be seen as being a hypocrite!
Honestly, I say this with exasperation and no ill intent- especially as I don’t know the ins and outs - if you can afford to go private then do it, don’t let your pride take centre stage. 10 years….shall we have the same conversation in 5 years time or shall we just deal with it.

I just think. Okay I went after the left. But the right too. Politics is not serving us. It’s a game. It’s so far from reality. And none of them are making the country better. Jesus. I could write an essay on how to fix this.

1 Like

And Burnham. Negotiating a return to Europe.
I voted in. But be open.

1 Like

I get your point, A lot of people feel like things go on and what is said publicly differs from reality. People want open, honest information. If it is going to hurt but be better in the long term then explain it. If he wants to rejoin the EU then tell us about the good points and the bad points… don’t be a brexiteer bus wanker… or a remoaner lack of inormation twit. We are not children and we do not need to be treated as such

Please do!
I’d be extremely interested in your solutions and your projections on how they would work and what they would do.

2 Likes

Be warned though flobs.. if he actually has good ideas we might have to vote for him if he runs. :joy:

1 Like

Ok. I am on it. Essay coming.

2 Likes

It might distract me from football!

1 Like

And I hate the words. “Cost of living crisis”. “Working people “.

Chapter 1 written.

1 Like

So is this just going to be your personal hate list?
You do seem to hate a lot of things :blush:.

1 Like

You are Andy Burnham. I claim my food bank voucher! :joy: