American education is a strange thing! I have two kids, a high school senior and a high school freshman.
To my mind, there should be a curriculum, set by the best expert educators. A core part of this should be fixed, let’s say English, mathematics, one or two sciences, a modern language - and then there should be some choice around the degree of emphasis in other subjects - history, geography, social science, music, numerous other things.
There can and should be rigorous debate to all of the above… but the debate should be done by the expert educators, and they set the curriculum. There is a good core to it, and enough variety for kids to have some latitude to pursue things that interest them.
I am talking about up to high school.
The whole thing should be taxpayer funded, and apolitical. Politics should stay out of it, apart from some of the taxpayers money should be used to educate children to a certain level, for the good of society.
So far, so normal. That’s how it should be… but it isn’t.
Politics is rife in education. Culture wars are being fought via education. And in America, the unusual aspect of it all, having grown up in England and been educated there, is the prevalence of alternate schools and home schooling.
If parents want to have control, home school your kid then! OR, leave it to the experts.
Right now the whole thing is a mess. Parents are trying to overreach, politics is stirring the pot, and the whole thing is a shitshow.