The Man Utd thread

Managing United will be one way to get himself a heart attack.

I think the better managers for United would be the guy who’ve got the worse results. Atleast among the last 4 hires.

For example

Ole < ETH < Rangnick< Amorim.

Maybe would rate Rangnick ahead of Amorim.

The great thing is that they’ve spent a billion pounds on players, the stadium is falling apart and they’ve no PSR wriggle room to do another squad overhaul.

So they appoint a ‘system’ manager who everyone could see would need to rebuild the squad to even stand a chance of his system being effective.

It’s really impressive stuff.

6 Likes

1000029721

@PeachesEnRegalia

Whaddya reckon?

3 Likes

My first thought when I saw him on the telly yesterday was ‘you fat bastard’.

Yes, but the question was comparing each manager’s first 16 league games.

1 Like

Maybe closing the canteen will get them a new wing back?

2 Likes

I guess I just wanted to make the point that even with Hodgson getting worse before he got fired, he still performed better than Amorim…

2 Likes

But he had far better players - Utd don’t have anyone comparable to Gerrard and Torres, and even a declining Reina was far superior to Onana.

Torres was shite at that point. Couldn’t hit the side of a bus, which is why he was sold off to Chelsea.

Trying to get the

“You guys are so screwed now” gif in that Avengers movie.

He had 9 league goals by the time he left in January, which is actually pretty remarkable given how poorly he was being used. Torres was definitely not the problem

2 Likes

images (76)

Closest I could find.

Not a chance.

Yes we had some top players (albeit Torres was already a shadow of himself by then), but in football you track far closer to your average or even worst player on your team than you do your best. People for some reason continue to treat Utd’s players like a collection of championship players getting an unexpected opportunity when what they are are players with collectively a ton of CL and international experience, with very few players not fitting that description. Look at our team that year. Ngog got 30 appearance because even when Torres was still here he was needed. Poulson, Konchesky, Jovanovic, Wee Jay, a half dead Joe Cole, that Greek lad at the back. Raw inexperienced versions of Kelly and Shelvey. Personnel wise we were shit, quite possibly the shittest we’ve ever been in my lifetime.

The turn around in the second half of the season was impressive and driven a lot by Kenny, both in terms of him simply being better than Roy and by just lifting the atmosphere around the club. But it was also driven by being given Suarez (and Carrol).

4 Likes

He wasn’t shit yet. But the signs of his downfall were there.

1 Like

A mignolet is better than Onana.

At least not his finishing.

His fitness and ability to remain on the pitch is what edged us to allowing him to leave.

Fully agree with this. Milner was one of the best transfers in recent history, very much one helping the club to change its overall mentality.

2 Likes

Probably wise

2 Likes

:thinking:

2 Likes