The Middle East Thread

Meanwhile, a poor 19-year old kidnapped by Hamas on October 7th is now confirmed killed, by Israeli bombs according to Hamas… (from the BBC website)

IDF confirms death of 19-year-old Israeli captive
image

The Israeli military has confirmed the death of a 19-year-old Israeli who was kidnapped by Hamas on 7 October.

Noa Mariciano was described as a fallen soldier. No cause of death is given, but the IDF says her family has been notified.

As we reported last night, a video was shared widely online in which Marciano identifies herself and says she had been held for four days. The footage then cuts to graphic images which appear to show the body of a young woman.

There is the normal assumption - as with all hostage videos - that the words are not her own.

Hamas claimed that Mariciano was killed in an Israeli air strike.


The highlighted part seems a bit bizarre. Was she a soldier?

1 Like

Well said:

2 Likes

This is excellent news. Tony is just the statesman to sort this out.

Here’s a plane ticket to Jerusalem, and from there I’m sure you can reach Gaza, where I’m sure Hamas would be delighted to see you. You have so many friends in The Middle East I’m sure you won’t find accommodation and transport difficult to arrange.

I know there isn’t a return ticket, don’t worry about it. We’ll sort that later.

1 Like

If you read the reports it’s a direct contact from Bibi. Not for any peace building but to operate from his existing office in Israel to help them whitewash their genocide in the Western media. He’s had plenty of experience with that so maybe a logical appointment

At that age, she normally would be doing her national service (from age 18, 2 years for women, 3 years for men, though many women do 3 years as well).

1 Like

:man_facepalming:

Yeah, that is the somber face of the medal. :see_no_evil:

But on the other hand:

There is still reason for hope as long as there remains an internal front of resistance facing the current fascist government.

2 Likes

That’s a good series of article from the Guardian to be fair. :+1:

2 Likes

It is important to understand that this is not remotely close to a new position. He is the chair of the RZP, and it (along with predecessor versions) has never accepted the existence of Gaza as an independent entity, nor the idea of such an entity in the West Bank.

Nevertheless, it’s still so chilling and infuriating.

The tragedy is that such a fanatical knobhead is allowed to hold an important ministerial position. And that is still relatively new.

2 Likes

Fucking hell!

But apparently THIS is what’s needed right now…

1 Like

It’s mad to me that officials of a terrorist organisation suffer sanctions instead of arrest.

I mean, a travel ban? Wtf is a travel ban? Are you telling me a member of an officially recognised terrorist organisation was previously allowed to travel around Britain as he pleased?

A travel ban, that’ll show the terrorists.

1 Like

I think Ezra Klein has been really good over this. He’s a Liberal New York Jew and and naturally fills that position you know exists but don’t hear much of - conceptually pro-Israel, but practically opposed to the way it conducts itself.

I posted his initial comments several weeks ago, but in the weeks since he’s hosted a really good series of conversations

His first two were very much focused on his perspective:

A conversation with two other very prominent US Liberal Jews about the difficulty treading the line they tread - The Jewish Left Is Trying to H… - The Ezra Klein Show - Apple Podcasts

If you accept Israel HAS to do something to respond, but think what it is doing is wrong, what SHOULD it be doing instead? - If Not This, Then What Should … - The Ezra Klein Show - Apple Podcasts

There was one fantastic one with a Palestine political scientists about her work trying to understand the view of the Palestinian people and the nuance required to understand the huge variability you get in polling results - She Polled Gazans on Oct. 6. H… - The Ezra Klein Show - Apple Podcasts

Then most recently he did a sort of point-counterpoint:

I think they are very much worth people’s time.

1 Like

fuck me, if Putin hasn’t pulled a bag of tricks here to take the spotlight off Ukraine.

the older I get, the less I believe in coincidence. divide et impera.

1 Like
1 Like

…but don’t worry, IDF is carrying out a precise and targeted operation inside Al Shifa.

1 Like

They’ve brought lots of boxes with big labels on them saying ‘medical supplies’ I’m sure it’ll be fine

The thing the hospital desperately needs is fuel and that the one thing they don’t bring and are blocking them from getting

2 Likes