UK Politics Thread (Part 5)

I’m not sure that the two are comparable, and I think Starmer’s action’s on Mandelson are more a case of wishful thinking, failure to do due diligence and pragmatism to the point of self destruction. I’m not sure there is anything that I’d put at the same level of egregious mistruthin’ as claiming the police advised you to stay away because of a security threat when they said no such thing.

Farage has a long standing record of lying and corruption that most other politicians would struggle to match. I think there should be some sort of parliamentary enquiry into him.

Globally no. That’s why the oil price tanked.

The UK hasnt got the same scale of leverage and simply cutting immigration to zero just won’t move that needle.

170k migrants isn’t going to reduce the cost of a loaf of bread or a tank of fuel.

It’s the same argument as the UK being responsible for 2% of global co2 emissions. You can’t have that argument and argue this is somehow different.

Similarly, if fuel was down by 5p a litre. The lorry delivering a load of baked beans would save how much? What would the saving per tin be? It won’t move.

Not comparable

Both can be true here. There was something very dark and disturbing around the whole thing with Mandelson, who I think was the cherry on top of a very dark cake.

Meanwhile, Farage has an equally muddy background of lies, supporters, financial dealings and the lies are just poor efforts to try and maintain this man of the people image he wants.

Drawing a league table on this shit is kind of pointless

In the eyes of most yes, but always somone who will delare A is not a concern because they think B is more serious

1 Like

if you say so…

I think it kinda does reduce wages and increase rents. 10 million people coming in over a decade need housing, they compete in the labour market and they need other things that are in limited supply.

Potentially with fair and proper housing building and not hoarding you can increase supply to try balance it but it´s definitely a factor.

There’s your problem though. Not the immigrants, it’s the numbers being built and the rental market.

I do. If it were true we’d have already seen prices reduce as immigration has fallen 48% in the last year.

Well, it´s half the problem isn´t it. Supply AND demand.

In theory we can just build more houses. In reality it´s not quite that simple. Although there are other aspects like housing stock not being used.

Maybe production has been cut to adapt to falling sales…

supply and demand and all that…

Jeez…

Mate, the UK population has still increased by a few hundred thousand NET in the last year.

That´s more demand, not less. To reverse prices, all other things being equal, you´d need mass deportations, theoretically. Not just cutting arrivals.

1 Like

224000 apparently.
So 224000 additional NHS patients.
Making the wild, but unlikely assumption they’re in families of 4 thats 55000 homes and 112000 school/ nursery places to be found.

2 Likes

Exactly, but @Bonus is arguing that prices should be coming down as immigration decreases. My point is that even if you cut immigration to zero, it won’t move the needle on prices. There’s too many other links in the chain that won’t decrease the price. They’ll just take the miniscule increase in profits. They always do. That’s a part of basic inflation

Ah yes. True unless supply increases a lot, which may happen in some industries but probably not in others

1 Like

prices should come down as the population decrease via less migration IMO,
less demand lower costs…

but as Liverdinner states the population is still increasing.

you didnt give this argument in costing not coming down, you laid it on ‘cost of production and so on..’.

if you had stated the population was still rising, we wouldn’t be here now, as is this reply…

kicking myself i didnt think of that, its been a long day…

1 Like

In Sky news last night rolled out Kwasi fucking Kwarteng to commentate the departed professor was “slightly under qualified” for his Cambridge post.

Who the fuck are you to say that?

3 Likes

Bet Rachel from accounts is glad she’s out of the limelight

1 Like

That’s the issue. If equal scrutiny was levelled on her she’d be under the cosh far more

She got hammered in the media for her “creative” CV writing