UK Politics Thread - read the rules before posting!

Isn’t it really just voting now to keep the worst out while hopefully getting a bit more in your pocket until inflation wipes that out.

Full Fact have got a really good tracker for Labour’s manifesto pledges and where they are on being met.

Loads of good stuff in there, if you want to look at what they’ve achieved in the two years they’ve been in power. A few missed promised, mostly on tax when reality slapped them in the face.

2 Likes

I think there is evidence to argue your point that the recovery was going okay.

Won’t disagree with your opinion on Cameron.

I don’t really get your point about 13 years and people wanting change. So the Tories Government ended for the same reasons?

Whether you or others agree with me or not, it is my opinion that we are generally blinkered. 13 years, typical Government life cycle. 14 years Government inherited a mess.

Labour did not incorrectly get the blame, they were in power. New Labour was very much pushing a financial/service based future and the sector lacked regulation.
Blame Labour for the Wars/Financial Crisis. Blame the Tories for Austerity and a poor handling of Covid, the Ukraine War. Blame Labour for the Iran War. Blame Leavers for Brexit.

Energy is better used in a positive manner so we should look forward and all try to make the UK and the world a better place to live.

A good read. A few debatable ones though.

On one hand Labour under Blair did indeed continue the programme of financial sector deregulation that started under Thatcher, and contributed to the subsequent unravelling of the global finance sector, so that’s a fair point - but also one you could point at pretty much any Government around the world.

But it still isn’t fair to claim that the financial crash - which started as a result of American toxic sub-prime mortgages being fraudulently AAA credit rated - was Labour’s fault. It simply wasn’t.

I’d also add Brown’s swift action in the immediate fallout are credited with saving the economy and also showing leadership to the rest of the world’s governments, who were largely flapping about in panic.

I don’t think those two points are the same. I don’t think that it can be argued that in 2010 the Tories inherited any kind of mess comparable with what Labour inherited in 2024.

But public perception matters, and that kind of timescale - maybe three election cycles - and people start feel that Governments are tired. I think it was the case with the last ones as well. The feeling of ‘we need a change’ was a lot more prevalent than ‘these fuckers have destroyed the economy’.

1 Like

It was a shit attempt at humour

1 Like

Well if you hadn’t worded it in Australian gobbledygook we might have got it :winking_face_with_tongue:

2 Likes

I have said vote Reform. Not because I love them but because the political system needs a change. The Civil Service needs a change. Benefits need a change.

A couple of years (they would not survive more ) might shake things up. Stop the stupid free market right (conservative) versus 1970s feck the rich left (Labour).

We need to stop talking and do things. Rwanda scheme would have stopped the boats but of course it was stopped by Labour - other countries like Italy have proved it worked.

We need radical change to the country and maybe Reform would be the light the blue touch paper that makes Tories and Labour change the status quo.

Oh and Liberal Democrat’s. It’s in the name. Nonsense.

We need radical change in this country. We will soon see looting like France.

I don’t often visit this thread and I’m very reluctant to enter this discussion, but I’ve just watched the Reform documentary and what seems to me to be the most disturbing element of it wasn’t the casual racism, sexism and bigotry, I’d expected that, but the way that all the Reform supporters, members and politicians agreed that they would be far more extreme once elected.
There’s a plan to trick the voters into thinking that they’re a mainstream party so they can enact fascistic policies when in power. They all espoused this view.
Sorry if this has already been discussed, but, as I said, I rarely visit this thread.

4 Likes

Well yes that is the framing. In reality it goes much much deeper and earlier.

Not that I like him. Wouldn’t trust him as far as I could throw him

I know is old fashioned, but I like living in a country where things like rule of law matter.

3 Likes

Have you thought about moving to one?

3 Likes

Should be great fun when this starts hitting doormats!

1 Like

@jaffod come on! yesterday i read all the way back to your post replying to @SBYM and i didn’t interpret that as saying everything is shit, everyone is shit and shit is shitter than shit has ever been.
If I was meant to understand everything you have ever said about uk politics, just like reform uk, that’s before my time! :joy: :grimacing:

I do like wasgij puzzles though. 38 posts or something since i retired last night and the bsst thing in the uk politics thread today was from a bloody Aussie.

We are in trouble :joy: :heart:

This is all starting to feel quite Brexit-y, in that people started convincing themselves that any kind of change was worth voting for, even if it would inevitably make everything much, much worse. As I said before, at some point we have to stop stepping on rakes.

It would represent a phenomenal risk to put a hard right populist with a proven track record of lying, division, and utter disregard for democratic scrutiny in number 10 on the proviso that his government would fall within a few years. Everything we know about populists is that they don’t relinquish power voluntarily once they have it. Do you think Trump is going to step aside in 2028?

And what makes you think that the fallout from the inevitable failure of a reform government would be a positive change to the status quo? It’s more likely to push people push further right?

Do you understand why there has been protest/rioting in France? It started as a protest about underfunding in the school system, and escalated to encompass a general frustration about cost of living and deteriorating public service - a big trigger for this has actually been Climate Change and the unsuitability of French infrastructure to cope with the extreme heat they are now routinely experiencing.

So I’m all for radical change, but I’m not sure how electing a party of billionaire funded, climate change denying, wealth worshipping, grifters reprints anything other than a radical continuation.

1 Like

Italy has a higher asylum rate than the UK. The UK rate has been falling since Labour came in and started processing the cases.

3 Likes

This may or may not be a fair way to look at it, but your post reminds me of when Trump was coming to the fore first time around. Lots of people over here were saying a similar thing. Politics is broken. Trump will shake it all up. Of course he will crack a few eggs along the way, but it will all be for the better.

7 Likes

Exclusive: Labour MPs asked planted questions in Commons

That’s why we need to find a way to change the MO of politics. It’s all parties. Snout in trough. Care about election not country. I’m t divorced from you or me.

To be fair. You ate right. But Trump is deranged!

1 Like

True, and yet there are Reports the EU are looking at some form of deregulation to make their banks more competitive.

I have never claimed it was Labours fault. But it happened under their watch and so they were partially responsible.
Yes, Brown got recognition but he has also openly admitted he got it wrong in the first place.

By the way I voted for Labour under the Blair/Brown Government.

You’re missing the point, you excused Labour and the Country voting for a different over as a 13 year cycle. But, at the same time the reason the Country elected the Labour Party was because of 14 years of Tory mismanagement. There is no point to argue, both Parties inherited a mess, wasn’t there a famous post it note left for the New Chancellor at the end of New Labour by Liam Byrne - sorry there is no money left - or something like that.
The Tories weren’t to blame for Covid, the Ukraine/Russia war but we still have to hold them accountable for some of their bad decisions.
But, yet again, we could point fingers at most Governments across the world.

I concur and yet all we heard under the Starmer Government was 14 years of Austerity. Did I mention they had a lower public vote than previous unsuccessful Labour election campaigns :grinning_face:.

I think it is clear, that despite a couple of in roads the Starmer leadership didn’t fail because of what they inherited. It was because they didn’t have a plan and they made a few u-turns on their policies. They didn’t provide any reassurance to the public.

Thank fully they cut their loses and replaced him with Burnham. Who, I believe is a much better Leader and one people can believe in.
I also believe that in Badenoch, Davey, Farage and Polanski we have a number of strong opposition parties.
Competition is healthy, Labour know they have to deliver and hopefully they do.