The strange thing is, is that Trump shook it up for a Term and the US then voted Biden in. He played it safe and then the US felt the necessity to go back to Trump.
I am not for a Reform Government but at the same time if they got elected I do not believe it would be the end of the World or the UK. I will say the same thing about the Lib Dem’s and the Greens.
All I want is strong leadership. Infact, It is strange, because for the first time in a while I actually feel confident in the leadership of all Parties.
Like most situations there is always a negative to a positive. There has been a decrease in small boats (was this all down to Labour or a carry on from what the Tories put in place) who knows.
Labour have done well at reducing the initial case assessment but referrals have now sky rocketed.
Admittedly, the case total is lower than its peak under the Tories.
I don’t think the Rwanda scheme was the best idea (and I appreciate my comment may be a bit inhumane) but at least the people with rejected asylum applications would have further to travel to reclaim asylum than the 1 in 1 out policy.
I think it is quite clear, whether people agree with it or not is that one of the predominant issues across Europe is immigration and until there is a balanced strategy across the Continent, there will only be further support for RW parties.
Do you mean immigration or asylum? Immigration tends to be required by the destination country, whereas asylum is primarily concentrated on nations bordering the place refugees are fleeing from. The latter is well regulated, but the countries that are on the frontier need a lot more assistance.
Like always you look at the opposition in such a positive manner
.
I can understand your point, but it can be looked at in both ways. Your view is that it would be much, much, worse and you are probably right but at the same time people sit in their comfort zone and put up with the Status Quo. I would rather step on a few rakes if it meant me getting across the field than play it safe for the fear of being hit in the face and still be in the same place.
I am pretty sure Climate Change is not the main trigger - happy for you to provide information to support your point - France’s debt has been spiralling for a long time. Over borrowing and weak bonds may be a more likely catalyst.
I am getting bored of repeating myself, France are/were the second largest economy in the EU. Yet, they are the ones unable to vote through a budget. Infact, how many Prime ministers have they gone through in the last two years?
Their national debt is 119% of GDP despite being part of the EU.
Protests in Spain and Belgium, oh how rosey it is in the EU.
Just did a quick search.
Arrivals on small boats taken as a daily average is between 60 & 100, so let’s call it 80 a day = 29k annually.
You have to assume that by taking that route they’re attempting to claim asylum.
Another quick search tells me that 38 - 42% of asylum claims are successful, so lets call it 40%.
So 60% of the 29k have no right to be here and you’d assume the authorities will eventually remove them.
I think a lot of the concern is where are they and are they being monitored during the process.
It’s clear there is no ideal arrangement in place with several articles highlighting NIMBY concerns.
Bottom line is, yes there are thousands of genuine cases who need assistance, but many more thousands who need to be controlled and removed.
And successive governments have failed to set up an effective system to implement this efficiently.
I think it is viewed as the same by a lot of people.
Immigration is where people decide to relocate for personal reasons, usually financial. Whilst Asylum is as a result of conflict/survival/persecution. However, polls suggest both are viewed negatively by a large number of the Countries voters.
I agree completely with the point you raise about Countries on the Frontier needing more assistance. This could also be said about the areas where Asylum seekers are housed in the UK. I am sure some peoples opinions may change if their local community was changed overnight by allocated housing.
I think you raise a good point.
Would it be fairer if we made Asylum applications easier via a safe route on the agreed consensus that anyone arriving legally is immediately deported?
I’m not sure if it is government policy or geopolitical situations, but the number of voluntary repatriations has gone up by about 50% since the Labour government got into power. That may just be that they are processing more cases, although a lot of it is assisted returns, which is possibly the cheapest way of moving people on.
I don’t think so. Wasn’t that was Milliband, years later when Labour were getting attacked for the financial crash, and some bright spark in the party thought apologising would make it go away.
That was a sickening episode in British politics.
An outgoing treasury leaving a note for the incoming party saying there is no money left was an inside joke in politics going back decades. It wasn’t to be taken seriously. The Cameron administration was the first Government to have the bad faith to weaponise it and take it public. Fucking shameful.
And I dispute that the Tories inherited a mess. There was work to do following the crash, but nothing a competent government couldn’t run with.
In particular Cameron and Osbourne were criticised for not taking advantage of historically low borrowing rates, and instead embarking on their absurd austerity program.
The protests/riots have quickly escalated to encompass a wide range of grievances, but the original protesting was carried out by students over the decline in education standards, teacher shortages, and dilapidated buildings - one of the main discomforts being the stifling, unmanageable heat they have experienced.
Just FYI, Migration Observatory are claiming that it’s a 62% success rate for 2018-2025 for small boat arrivals specifically.
Source: People crossing the English Channel in small boats - Migration Observatory
I did say it was a quick search.
So even at 62%, that’s still over 10,000 (can they be called illegals?) in the country with little or no control over their daily movements until the system removes them.
True,given that Farage is one of Trumps hero worshippers and a suckhole the most likely effect of a reform govt is Trumpistan 2-0 20 miles off the French coast…not convinced most in the UK are hanging out for that,and not much of Europe,either!
Based on that link, that is people who were granted asylum. So they are here legally and are known and accounted for by the authorities.
“Illegals” is an American term, but visa violations are what account for most people being in the country without appropriate authorisation. A lot of those will be students and visiting family members who have failed to renew visas on time. So they are known by the authorities.
What no-one seems to be concerned about is people who have been shipped into the country in a clandestine manner and are below the radar, working in sweatshop factories, the sex industry, or as domestic servants for rich families. The current government has cleared the backlog of cases (I think it was about 6,000 last year) but that is likely to be the tip of the iceberg.
The National Crime Agency does have a Modern Slavery Unit, but the funding of that is actually being cut. Seemingly people are happy to shout abuse to the coast guard and RNLI when they are actually doing their job, but when it comes to actual crime, it’s tumbleweed.
I was referring to the 38% who are refused asylum
They are removed, either from detention or voluntarily. It can take a while, as they can appeal an asylum finding,but for the last year, there were 9669 forced removals (which would match closely with your estimate). There were 3 times as many voluntary removals.
Wasn’t aware they were in detention during the application process
That’s what the whole Bibby Stockholm thing was about, wasn’t it?
Thought that was just to meet accommodation needs.
Now it’s hotels and old Army barracks isn’t it?
No, Asylum Seekers are not detained in the same way a prisoner would be. But they are closely monitored while awaiting a decision on their claim.
Having said that, the temporary accommodation they are held in is not that much better than prison, in reality.
Asylum seekers can be held if it is judged that there is a risk of them absconding, or if there is dispute over their identity.
Asylum seekers are also detained if they have been refused asylum and are awaiting deportation.
Basically the only way someone is ‘illegal’ is if they have arrived illegally, haven’t claimed asylum or have evaded the authorities and are at large in the country (very, very few people meet this criteria)