UK Politics Thread - read the rules before posting!

Someone mentioned this earlier in the thread, and I’ve arrived at the conclusion they were right.
Most decisions or gestures made by politicians is driven by the desire to be re-elected, not by some deep desire to help the the general population.

1 Like

Yes that was me! Someone has to tackle the structural issue. We are pretty much taxed to the max. We have huge debt that is costing a huge amount to service. Public spending is increasing so requiring more debt or more tax. Its not a hard calculation.

Everyone believes growth is the way out and partially it is - although the taxes on business are stifling that or rather killing it stone dead. You have to tackle the underlying issue.

or (tongue in cheek) maybe we can redistribute the debt and people want to do with wealth :wink:

That and the other major issues with the UK economy - over reliance on imported energy, deindustrialisation etc etc

In 2000 the uk debt was just below 1 trillion, now its around 3 trillion, if that aint proof that both the major parties are failures, then i dont know the answer, seemingly nor does the political system.

1 Like

But you have to wean the country off welfare (the vast majority pensions - before people accuse me of saying everyone is a slacker). You have to fundamentally restructure the NHS not just chuck more money at it. You have to seriously look at the size of the state & public sector… etc. (I know some will say you have to take the money off the millionaires - but those leaving leave a huge hole in the tax take).

its a rebasline of the UK. What do we want to be as a nation? Where do we want to stand in the world? How do we want to structure the state? How do we want to support our people?

1 Like

I don’t know who you mean by we however certain are nowhere near taxed to the max!

I think that it has to be asked where ‘growth’ comes from?
I reckon most spend far too much on housing which leads to immense problems of circulation of ‘money’. Wages are another big concern, standard of living is falling for many. These 2 things put together is causing much of the social unrest and strange voting decisions we are seeing imo.
An example ‘teachers’ in France used to earn 2,5 times the minimum wage (1996 I think) now they earn just 1,5 on average. I can also state that to live on the minimum wage is damn hard. (This lowering of standard of living has hit many groups Pompiers, Police, Fishermen, certain agricultural sectors …
Surely if these people had more to spend that would create some growth.

4 Likes

of course. We need to tax millionaires more!

25/26 tax around 37% of GDP. Sure it could go a little higher but not much. The Laffer curve still resonates.

The question is what you get for it. Denmark and Sweden are taxed more but the measures of self reported life satisfaction are much higher than the UK with public services and social protection generally stronger.

Damn - I promise myself everyday not to post in the politics forum!

How do you wean people off their pensions , euthanasia ?

1 Like

Didn’t the Tories try that in 2020?

2 Likes

That would be very Logans Run :).

No. But look at the triple lock, maybe incentivise people more to use private pensions. God forbid I say this but means test the basic pension - although it’s not a lot.

I don’t know. I have not really written my restructure the UK economy paper yet. But it has to be all looked at as a system. not individual elements.

1 Like

Not really, if it works at all it is at the extremes and while there are a few cliff edges in the tax system where it may apply, generally speaking I don’t think we are anywhere near close to that in most cases within the UK.

The edges are huge though. The top 1% of earners pay 27% of UK income tax. You have to incentivise them to pay it. That’s even before all the other taxes involved. The removal of Non Dom status has been a net loser for the treasury.

I don’t think by itself that shows anything other than the debt has increased in nominal terms.

It shows failure to recognise the structural issues the Uk has given the changing global landscape and the fact most of our systems are 100s of years old.

It also shows an over reliance on debt to solve issue rather than genuine discussion and solution.

oh and it shows we have built a spending model that requires sustained economic growth, but we haven’t built an economy particularly well equipped to deliver it. That is one thing I agree with Burnham on - regional in equality in productivity.

I think it is too early to say one way or another whether it has been a net loser. Lots of reporting either way but until next year’s self assessment returns and HMRC review on the issue.

If it is indeed happening on a greater scale than expected, I think the capital/ inheritance taxes will be the larger driver than the income taxes.

1 Like

I have to go and put my daughter to bed (cannot afford a Butler).

But this country needs to stop treating economic growth as the means of avoiding difficult choices, and start making the difficult choices that allow growth to happen.

No, by itself the figure @odin_telamon gave is meaningless.

1 Like

Maybe but if you think we do not have a debt problem you have your head so far in the sand its in Australia!

For most of them that is all that drives them,terrified of losing their security blanket!

1 Like

Unfortunately voters from all sides are entrenched in their deep rooted loyalties to their chosen parties.
They will vote for them regardless of political climate and current environment.

Politicians know this, and know how easily manipulated these people are.
They prey on their gullible nature to secure their only priority - Re-election

1 Like