Sorry isn’t the pensions you guys are talking about, technically the people’s own money they earned throughout their working lives by the employee and employer…there are other pensions?
Pensions that contributed to via National Insurance. One used to have to have so many paid years (stamps) iirc. Not sure what it is now. State pension.
Different from a private pension.
It is money one has paid in, aye.
So if you work, you get pension paid by yourself and your employer, and on top of that, there is an additional pension paid by the government through National Insurance? And the contention is this additional pension? We used to have pension schemes long time ago in Singapore but gotten rid of them as it was not sustainable. However, I am sure the pensions paid by the government are funded through government investments? I mean the contribution to the national insurance (and i suppose the citizen is the one who paid this contribution?) has to grow enough to fund the pension payout many years down the road? And if is not sustainable, and the UK still wants to keep this scheme, then they got to find a way to fund it through growing the contributions more efficiently?
The state pension is an entitlement based on years worked and paid for by National Insurance contributions from existing workers. It doesn’t have an investment fund behind it. Private pensions are a savings scheme which is encouraged by tax breaks.
Not quite but sort of.
Private pensions are money you earn and pay in.
A state pension is an entitlement you have when you reach pension age - now 67. Everyone gets it from public money.
Of course you pay tax and national insurance to the government that contributes to the state pension overall pot - not directly your own.
And maybe thats where the government needs to do better? Because if the pension is just letting the worker insurance contribution sit there and paid out, it will surely not be sustainable? The more productive thing is to use those contributions and make investments to let this part of the pension self funding?
Cheers lads/lasses/undeclared. I struggled for the right wording. It is sort of your own money but not a personal pot. cheers.
The UK does not have a sovereign wealth fund. We do have a National Wealth Fund (NWF), established in October 2024. It operates more like a government investment bank than a conventional sovereign wealth fund.
Pensions pretty much come from the tax take. That means the pension is funded by future tax payers. So we have a future pension liability and no investment to pay for it.
It’s a sort of historical thing, because when the pensions started, they were paid out to people on their retirement date without prior contribution.
It’s a perfectly valid system for doing it, but it does make assumptions about a stable demographic. What has thrown it is greater life expectancy and a lower birth rate. The former has been tackled by raising the retirement age and the latter by immigration.
It all comes down to people and nations not being the same thing.
Peope on average living longer was not really factored in, i don’t think.
Young people struggling to find work, therefore struggling to payback education loans, in some parts having to claim benefits through no fault of their own… puts extra stress on the system.
In a thriving economy the system works.
The other issue is how to increase the pay out year on year. In line with inflation or earrings growth or something else. That’s now called the Triple lock.
It increases by inflation, average earnings growth or
2.5%. Whatever is the highest.
That is the even more unsustainable bit too. If we linked it to average earnings growth we would incur less liability I think. But it’s political. Taking money from pensioners.
And what do pensioners do? They vote…
It been or being changed to double lock?
yeah for bloody brexit… don’t shoot me for saying that word.
The power of compound interest. Even more politically controversial is the winter fuel payment, which was only ever intended as a quick fix. The thing with that is that is went from being a support for short term high energy costs, to a “bonus” that pensioners expected to buy their grandchildren’s Christmas presents with.
This is what makes the current antipathy towards immigration insane. Older people expecting a shrinking pool of younger people to fund an ever lengthening, comfortable retirement, while simultaneously voting in favour of parties/policies to stop immigrants coming in and bolstering the workforce.
I get a £10 bonus at xmas from PIP. don’t take that off me
it pays for an out of date loaf of bread if i put 10p towards it
edit: They could remove that as a saving money method. Not sure what that would amount to but someone surely knows the numbers in here.
What is the state pension? £13k. That’s not enough to live on. You have to incentivise people to save. But - I hate to say it - this Government is doing entirely the opposite,
But its part of the whole structural reform of the economy that is required. Everything else is fiddle while Rome burns.
Not sure. Its still unsustainable in a thriving economy. You still need people to save their own pension, to create jobs for young people and want them to take them, and reduce the welfare bill. The leap in disability related payments since Covid is mad - a lot self reported.
Despite people thinking I am some right wing, Burnham hating, Reform voter - I want a safety net. Its absolutely vital and morally right in a decent society.
Its just the net is now cast way too wide and provides a reason not to work rather than a safety net if you can’t.
I understand your feelings on the subject. I think you have some similar view to mascot believe it or not… the working person needs to be better off in work rather than out of work. Better off means once essential bills are paid you still have a fair bit of leisure money/money one could save.
People will work, it is about how do people who have been out of work for a while get the chance. We as a nation need a plan of action, a sustainable one, not some knee jerk reactive thing that backfires and is then left for the next lot to deal with. We don’t need chaos.
The big issue with PIP is that it is about self reporting - not about actual medical fact. Whilst some might not see it… getting those people who can still work, whilst giving them support, will reduce the bill and also bring in more tax! we can’t just cull them though without the jobs to put people into.
I think then the system works. Sometimes you’ve used certain disabilities and that’s got peoples backs up.