UK Politics Thread - read the rules before posting!

The UK is seen as a cash cow.

1 Like

this was in reply to Dane complaining his employers dont look past the peice of paper.

you can wiggle out of this, theres enough room for you to do that and feel clever, but its pretty obvious what you meant. (higher education shows commitment and intelligence)… it shows nothing more and nothing less than on the job training. just different.

gonna leave it before i get banned.

file it away

1 Like

He hasn’t quoted you has he? My understanding is this is the frustrations @Redbj has with trying to engage with you.

@Mascot this is nail on head. This is the frustration people have with you.
You are a self proclaimed Liberal, who genuinely believes in a fair society and I think everyone respects that. However, there is a bias as to who you believe is allowed to feel maligned and if an opinion does not align with your own views, you very rarely give it consideration.

Another thing, is you expect a direct response to your points and then cherry pick what you respond to. @Redbj was very fair in his response to you, and you ignored all of it. Got defensive and deflected it back onto him. Rather than acknowledge his points, you have tried to put him on the back foot by claiming foul play.

Anyhow, have a good day. Nothing personal

@Lynch04 what sort of Jobs or industries are we seeing discussed here?

Legal experts, Accountants,Plumbers, electricians, gas engineers, roofers, bricklayers. Things of that nature?

If i require the use then i want them qualified to a high standard. The business can always pay for the training in a lot of cases.

A lot of well educated and intelligent folk get passed over in all industries due to who you know and not always what you know. That happens to people trying to et work in a local takeaway just in the same way it happens to people with and without degrees at more societal perceived great positions.

Perhaps it affects the business insurance / liability employing people that don’t have hte right certificate/paper?

Perhaps i am not understanding the debate?

1 Like

As mentioned earlier regarding my son, left college at 16, rare in NZ.

He is now a qualified drainlayer and regularly save Tiaki Wai, what was Wellington water money apltering plans drawn up be well educated engineers etc.

You don’t have to have a degree to prove your intelligence, for me you have to have a keen interest, drive or determination in something that pushes you to achieve.

When at school I was in the top form, but had nodrive to achieve or be the best, probably was too immature.

However, when I trained to be a PE officer, in the prison service, I had the interest and drive to achieve and wanted to be the best. I was top or near the top in nearly every qualification, exam or coaching session.

I honestly wished I had that same drive, determination or maturity at school/college

1 Like

My biggest regret at not going to uni was missing out on the (compulsory?) gap year travelling the world

3 Likes

I didn’t even know that was a thing when I first went to college. Someone asked me what I did between school and university and I told them that I worked in a chocolate factory. They asked were, and I perplexed them by saying near Liverpool. Apparently I should have been in Switzerland or somewhere.

3 Likes

I wasn’t even referring to the topic of the debate. :rofl:
All I was doing was agreeing with a Poster, who felt their views were not being given fair consideration by another member.

I think we agree here.
To answer your question(s) genuinely, we all want a good service but where does it start or stop? If I ring up a Service providers customer service, I don’t wait an hour to get through and then request a training certificate before I allow them to deal with my issue. There has to be some kind of trust in society.

There definitely has to be some kind of regulation/best practice. Especially in public facing roles. Drivers need a licence, kitchen staff need hygiene training, certain trades need different cards and yes this is all down to insurance/ass covering/ticking the boxes.
I am a Site Manager and we always check their Cards to make sure they are compliant, it doesn’t mean they are any good or going to work in a safer manner. We also get them to sign their RAMS so that they confirm they understood the Risk Assessment and Method Statement, it doesn’t mean they have read it. But if something happens, they have declared they know what they are doing and it also gives me a reason to fuck them off site if they aren’t :rofl:.

In regards to the whole academic qualification, higher education it is a bit backwards. Reading between the lines ( sorry if I have misinterpreted it) but @mascot wants to penalise children for attending private schools because they are privileged but then favours people with a degree over those who don’t on the perception that they are better suited - which may be a result of the people not being able to go to Uni because they couldn’t afford it, or simply didn’t want to.

My best mate and I done a College course in business studies. I passed, he failed, yet I am not the one who has a business posting ÂŁ?m profit a year. :+1:t2:

1 Like

You are living proof that education system is the ‘golden ticket’! :joy: ended up in a choc factory.

1 Like

I got my first job at around 11 or 12, delivering newspapers then butcher meat and milk.
I then washed pots & pans before leaving school at 16 to start an apprenticeship.

Around the age of 24, while serving as an Army recruit military instructor, I was staggered by the number of (non academic) who didnt have the first idea of how to use an iron or boot polish.

Having worked in another industry where I interacted with several post graduates, my assumption is that they would have been worse.

Basing this purely on my experiences of extremely clever individuals displaying little or no common sense or practicality.

4 Likes

I have a saying, which I stand by. The problem with common sense, is that it is not that common.

A letting agent offered me the opportunity to carry out repairs on their properties, but insisted that I provide a risk assessment for each job.
Weren’t prepared to pay me for the time it would take to write one though.
I politely declined their offer

1 Like

Thank you for the reply, I know you didn’t really talk about the subject in hand previously but thought i’d ask you for your understanding. Help to get the thread away from where it appeared to be headed.

Also had a little chuckle after i misread the word hygiene for lingerie :rofl: deary me!

Yep agree that a bit of paper doesn’t guarantee standard or safety. I think we do sort of trust that if we phone for a particular service - after a bit of research - that they will be a regulated certified service.

I believe that the higher standard of teaching is at private schools, were i live now in the welsh valleys, they struggle t get the best, they don’t have the money. For example, my daughter was diagnosed with ASD and now we have issues with the school as they don’t have the staff member to cater for her needs, she is now stuck at home whilst we try to get some resolution. Shes been give a place in a new school… sept 2027! I would gladly pay for her to go private/public route if i had the money but i don’t. That may well offer her a better route into work or higher education if i could.
I am not against people being able to give their kids a better education because they can afford it … I don’t like the thresholds that feel so low for working parents, meaning their kids can’t get that financial help so readily.

Just make things more accessible for everyone. It’s a bit like i can get a key for the diabled loos but most folk will have to go up 6 flights of stairs to relieve themselves.

My first job was as an office junior. There was a snag to this position, I had to remove property from vehicles that had been in road traffic accident, been abandoned , stolen, cut n shuts, ringers and severe incidents causing death. It was an horrendous job for a 16 year old. ÂŁ1.81 an hour. I hated it. Blood, drug needles and the belongings of people who had died.

I think Labour increased the minimum wage or set a min wage for 16 year olds about 8 months or so after i quit.

44 hours a week and emergency taxed on it too :joy:

So 6bn increase in welfare to save later? Maybe.

I can definitely confirm that undergraduates were like that. Generally, the ones that were capable of looking after themselves were from a working class or military background.

This is going back to the 1980s, but there was a very sexist side to this, because they seemed to regard basic housework as “women’s work”. There were quite a few that made regular trips home to get their washing done.

Why are you even writing to me. I’ve explained that I have absolutely zero interest in any debate with you. Stop wasting your time.

No, it isn’t. I meant what I said. Having a degree is a great way to show that you have the qualities I mentioned.

[=“Mascot, post:1046, topic:6004”]
But what it did teach me was a broader academic discipline - around things like research, study, critical thinking, analysis. All things that are incredibly useful and valued by employers.
[/quote]

At no point did I mention intelligence. And deliberately so. I’m experienced and smart enough to understand that intelligence comes in a variety of forms.

You should apologise for your insinuation of elitism. You are better than that.

3 Likes

We should establish some ground rules to stop this sort of thing. :expressionless_face:

2 Likes

I think it happens when one tries to read something that is not there. I don’t think it is hard to understand what mascot said if one takes it on face value. Redbj from what irecall is normally a decent chap. Hopefully they can just shake hands, animosity, especially online, is just wasted energy. Fingers crossed.