We’re massively off topic so I’m replying in the former players’ thread.
Clyne was a decent purchase for where we were at the time as a club. He was solid, nothing more. I felt he was too easily beaten by a ball played to the back post but other than that he was ok one-on-one, ok crosser, that’s about it. He was unfortunate with injuries and then other personal issues but equally, that allowed Trent to break through.