But he got through it, which suggests a certain level of mental toughness. 
Mental toughness cannot get a strained hamstring through a premier league game. He got through his own issues because of individualized medical care, patience and understanding.
5 Likes
Milner is also out with a pulled hamstring.
Mentally weak too?
3 Likes
As I said further up, Keita was fuming when sat down with the physio vs Brighton. Very much looked like he was being told he was being replaced and he didnāt want to be. That doesnāt strike me as the attitude of someone who is mentality weak about their body.
Klopp brought in a guy to basically get people like Keita fit and stay fit. Hamstring issues happen to most footballers and it was clear we overplayed Keita due to injures
1 Like
Iād hate to see how often heād play if he wasnāt āoverplayedā. Fuck me.
1 Like
They can both be true at the same time. He could have been overplayed after the first couple of injuries, that never led him to properly recovering after those, which goes back to what @Limiescouse was saying.
I canāt for one understand why people are so quick to want to get rid. JĆ¼rgen quite clearly likes him, and he usually plays when fit. And makes an immense difference too.
3 Likes
It can also be that on paper it wasnāt a big risk and that shit happens, no matter how good people and specialists we have. We donāt have to find/put blame on someone in every single situation.
6 Likes
It was something like 6 games in a row in the space of around 15 days, with a small break for the cup game, thatās a big workload for any player.
The problem is his contract. Its quite a high one as we expected him to be our new star midfielder when he arrived. Although he plays well when on the pitch heās not really contributing enough to merit the contract he is currently on (even if its no fault of his own).
So what do we do? His current contract ends in 2023.
Do we extend it? Almost certainly means matching the wage he currently doesnāt justify. Probably means increasing it.
Do we let him run down his contract? Even thatās not perfect as his contract distorts other contract negotiations for extending with existing players and signing new players. Players who contribute more or are brought in with the aim of contributing more will want to be in line. Then we lose a multi million pound asset for nothing and the club havenāt been acting like we can afford to bin that kind of money these days.
So a lot of us see a sale next summer for whatever we can get being the best option. Itāll help pay for his replacement. If we wait till 2023 we still need to buy his replacement but have no help towards it from a Keita sale.
I doubt anyone dislikes Keita as a person and itās stupid when people blame a footballer for their own injury issues, it comes from frustration but nobody suffers more than the player who gets the injuries. But realistically I think many see a sale as the clubs best option.
2 Likes
If those 6 games included the Atletico game, wasnāt he hooked at half time? And against Utd, he was carried off just after half time, so he didnāt actually play 6 full games.
I think that was planned though?
Definitely not planned that oneā¦
In all seriousness though, thatās still quite a few games in a short period of time.
playing 45 minutes is definately less load on the player than playing 90ā¦im not doubting thatā¦
ā¦but it doesnt āhalveā the load. mentally and physically, starting/getting āupā for the game is the major stress load.
1 Like
Sadly I think this will lead to many feeling disappointed with the outcome. You tend to underestimate how much JĆ¼rgen values a stable squad, and for that matter, how much of our lack of transfer activity was driven by him. At this moment, itās probably more likely that weāll see him get a new contract extension than him getting soldā¦
3 Likes
I think most likely scenario is him running his contract down and moving on for free. Klopp likes a settled squad but one CM in per year over the next few hardly flies in the face of that. But what Klopp is extreme in is considering what the player wants. If its mutual that everyone thinks Keita should move on he will but if the player is adamant about wanting to stay I think Klopp accepts that. Then he runs down his contract and gets a big goodbye and thank you like Lallana. Another player too injury prone to extend but wanted to be here so wasnāt forced out.
1 Like
I for one hope heās given a new contract. Heās too good just to allow to walk out the door for nothing.
Why not a scenario where Keita retains his current basic wage, but with higher incentives tied to appearances and performances? It looks like we are holding the cards in this situation, with the player liking it here (supportive environment and team mates) and few clubs likely to pay a high wage for him even if he leaves. The possible stumbling block could be his agent, so perhaps more money down that area thenā¦
Didnāt Houllier send him to France to have back essentially reshaped by a specialist?
He aināt getting that if he doesnāt contribute a fair bit more between now and then. Adam (and Gini) did a fair bit more than just run down their contracts to earn their goodbyes
You always say things like this, and accuse other people of conjectureā¦
The fact is that Naby Keita is a player whoās Liverpool career has been shattered by injuries, and the money available in the game, especially at the level that Naby might look to rebuild his career, is just not there. Those two things do not suggest there is a market there for Naby.
Even if you want to go full Mourinho and āmake it clearā that a player should leave, there is absolutely no point to this unless there is a place for the player to go and a result for the club in terms of income.
That doesnāt really help us though, does it? Thatās virtually giving him away. You might as well keep Naby, if those are the terms.
1 Like
I think I remember Ryan Nelson playing through a match with a torn hamstring, either for his club or for New Zealand at the World Cup?