THE ANFIELD NOISE

Which CM do you want?

  • Florian Neuhaus
  • Renato Sanches
  • Saul Niguez
  • Youri Tielemans
  • Nicolo Barella
  • Ryan Gravenberch
  • Yves Bissouma
  • Eduardo Camavinga
  • Other (please state)

0 voters

So, things have started to move on the outgoings from, and it sounds like we’re not far away from having raised £45m this summer.

We’ve been linked to a metric shit-ton of CMs already this summer, most of which sound like good to excellent options, so who do YOU want us to splurge our new-founds funds on?

If choosing the Other option, could I ask that it either be someone we know to be available/reasonably priced/ideally linked to us in some way, shape or form?

How come Camavinga didn’t get short listed for the pole?

Because obviously I forgot :joy:

Added but the two people who voted will need to do so again.

Do we need to add Hendo to the list? :rofl:

Yet he’s the only one I ever mention (apart from Barella but that’s in a very negative sense so doesn’t count), I am really frustrated that my persistence hasn’t paid off. :cry: :angry: :rofl:

No!

(10 characters)

He’s been added!

1 Like

Thanks! :smiley: (extra body required).

Camavinga by a mile.

2 Likes

I also voted Camavinga, but for me he’s the fantasy signing. If we’re talking more realistic, I probably favour Neuhaus.

But I’d be very happy with Barella or Niguez also.

I’m less enthused by Bissouma (style/quality) and Sanches (fitness), and I don’t really know much if anything about Gravenberch.

Camavinga first Gravenberch second as think we need to be aiming for the future so guys in their mid 20s don’t make as much sense to me.

Florian Neuhaus for me. We’re replacing our most dependable central midfielder of the last five years so bringing in a kid doesn’t make sense to me, we need someone on the cusp of taking that next step that we’d be happy playing week in, week out.

Saul Niguez is a player I don’t know much about, couldn’t tell you the difference between him and Koke to be honest and he comes with huge wages and a rocky season behind him and I’m always suspicious when a club is so openly keen about moving someone like him on.

Camavinga and Gravenbach are still too raw for me. Paying a huge fee for potential that they may not realise and probably not yet of the standard and dependability we need in light of the issues we have in CM. Sanches worries me on the injury front, Tielemans is too expensive for the player he is and Inter aren’t selling Barella.

Bisouma would be the second choice but some way behind Neuhaus and given the fee that they extracted out of Arsenal for Ben White I think they’ll want a silly fee for him as there’s no pressure to sell him now.

2 Likes

Fabinho, Thiago and Henderson would be ahead of anyone we buy for CM. We will also have Jones, Milner and possibly Keita and/or Ox.

And Camavinga and Gravenberch are kids in the same way Alexander-Arnold was when he started playing as our first choice RB week in week out. They’re already very good and could be relied on. Not that they’ll be “starters” straight away.

1 Like

3 Likes

Completely different types of players.

1 Like

Yep, might as well have put my picture up in the little art project rather than Gerrards.

In theory yes. But from the second the season ended and we knew Gini was going everyone has been panicking about the fitness issues in CM and needing to bring the average age down. So I’d want someone capable of being a 40 game a season player should Henderson go down in week one or Ox and Keita continue with their current fitness issues. I think that’s too much to expect from teenagers.

They might be the same age but they aren’t the same in that Trent was on our books and those two would cost a lot of money. If Trent’s development had stalled, you sell him for a decent fee and no harm or foul. You buy a teenager for a big fee and their development stalls, you lose a ton of cash when you move them on.

We have a young development prospect already in Jones so adding another in that bracket isn’t the way I’d go. Someone in our usual 23-24 type range makes more sense to me. More experienced, still not in need of playing every week but also not going to have their development stunted as badly should that be the case and then they’re prime age as we phase out the old boys.

2 Likes

There’s experience and then there’s experience. Some players play week in week out but never getting the type of experience we need.

Camavinga already has caps for an extremely good France side, experience in CL and EL as well as 67 League appearances. He’s also got a winners medal for a trophy winning the French Cup.

Bissouma in comparison despite being 5 years older, walks into a not very impressive/successful Mali side, only has 66 more league appearances, never been involved in winning any trophies and has never played in the proper EL or CL at all.

Even Gravenberch only 6 months older than Camavinga has decent experience with 2 Dutch cups and 2 Eredivisie titles, 7 caps for the Netherlands already, CL and EL experience and 42 League appearances for a team competing for titles.

I prefer experience that’s the right type of experience.

Houssem Aouar if he is available at a reasonable price. Lorenzo Pellegrini is another one I would look at.

Kalvin Phillips would have been one of my choices, but his price is likely to have sky rocketed even further after the Euros.

1 Like