If I’m reading this correctly, they are not dissimilar, are they? Alcantara seems like a better and more frequent tackler, while Andre seems to have played much more often as a defensive midfielder according to distribution of touches per field thirds. He’s also physically similar to him, hopefully minus the injuries, so I think I can say that I’m sold on idea of buying him in January.
Before he came to Liverpool, I had thought of Alcantara as a silky playmaker (probably because Bayern were so dominant that he didn’t have to defend, haha). I can’t describe how positively surprised I was to see him get stuck in both on ground and in the air, that aspect of his game is really underrated. It’s a crying shame that we had only about a year and a half of him. Hopefully we get Andre and he rights that wrong.
Fbref is a poor judge on its own - Fabinho, Henderson and Milner (especially) looked pretty good on it last year and we had people claiming Elliot was almost as good as De Bruyne based off Fbref.
That said, Andre still looks clearly better there. Better passing, much better running with the ball and significantly better defensive stats.