The Unreliable Rumours Discussion Thread (Part 1)

Bit of a strange post. Burnley have almost no impact on us whatsoever

8 Likes

Yes but perhaps I think adding his extra physical presence would make them even more combative and when we play them - especially with encouragement to ‘leave something’ on our players in any challenges. Anyway I’m happy if we can get 10m for him (maybe with a 20% sell on fee!) and if he goes off and has a good career.

Fair enough. I do think the Burnley apprehension is a result of the scars of the likes of Stoke rather than any real trouble they’ve given us. Yes we always get a game but 10 wins, 2 draws and 2 defeats over the course of 12 recent years reflects a relatively safe result when we play them considering one of those draws was after we won the league last year and this years loss was in the middle of the most inexplicable run of results at home in the Club’s entire history.

Also, our team are not pansies. That apprehension is also a holdover from the past. We have more than enough steel in that velvet glove of ours. Phillips going to Burnley really shouldn’t be causing anybody any trepidation. If anything, it will help against the real pansies in the league such as Arsenal, Spurs and even City when they come up against it.

3 Likes

Not against Burnley , Just don’t want Douche to stay in the leagues. Guys like him, Allardyce , Pulis with their negative style of play don’t deserve to be managing in the highest level.

Let Brighton , Southampton make a bid on the amount quoted… Fair enough

3 Likes

Ben Mee did break Joe Gomez’ leg two and a half years ago.

6 Likes

Oh come on. Dyche was very clear on the matter. It was an honest tackle in a contact sport - Joe Gomez’s leg was there to be won.

8 Likes

This was when Joe played RB. Would hate to see him at RB again.

1 Like

Knew we would get linked sooner or later with McGinn, but nah, the mentioned price is too high.

5 Likes

Pfff, that wouldn’t even buy his right bootlace

1 Like

Just heard that we’re planning to move for Astonvillania midfielder Jean Maginniho. Don’t know anything about him, but him it’s true. Sounds a cracking player.

McGinn’s a good player (right @ZinedineBiscan?!) but no way we’re paying £50m for him.

4 Likes

If true, I wonder if they genuinely value him at that or whether it is a deliberate effort to keep Villa from losing too many players in one window now that they expect Grealish to be on his way.

I think we were rumoured to be interested in him a year or two ago as well…

McGinn is far too inconsistent. Against the Czech Republic he literally looked like he had only heard of football through the radio and decided to give it a try.

Big Charlie Adam vibes.

10 Likes

This is real madrid esque, buy up all the weapons other clubs have to stop you scoring. That’ll leave us with just VVD (and Millie if he gets the call) to push those thugs around.

Dyke might dissagree with that! :wink:

1 Like

I see the McGinn rumours as smoke and mirrors. I just can’t see how Edwards and Klopp would go and splash our that kind of money for McGinn, who’s 27 this year. Even at £30m I’d be a bit surprised we would go for him.

I like him and he’s a decent player, and would be good to add to the ranks, but when there are others out there linked with far higher ceilings, such as Bissouma and Nehaus, I’d be a bit disappointed by a signing like him for big money.

3 Likes

It’s rubbish for subscribers, “when Klopp gets around to” I think Klopp would have thought about replacing Gini several months ago you could make the point that Thiago factors into that.

50m? I don’t even know why people give this stuff credibility seems to have made something about Klopp and then connected it to McGinn in a analysis piece.

It’s Pearce talking from his arse, must be low on subscribers this month.

10 Likes

10000% I’d hazard a guess Klopp would prefer Thiago over McGinn, just ever so slightly… If we were going to try and sign a Scottish midfielder it would be Gilmour when the chavs have finally finished with loaning him out.

3 Likes

Meh. Whole article seems to be predicated on fact Klopp must have once asked publicly if McGinn ever stops running, pretty thin.

I’d be about as excited to sign him as I was for Gini (not very) but would be happy to have another Scottish player in the team. Don’t really know a lot about him, he played a lot of minutes for a Villa team that exceeded expectations, which is large plus in my book.

1 Like

Pearce has been more of a hack than usual lately.

3 Likes

Screw Dyche, he was tuning his inner lard arse when he spoke about us.

Completely forgot about the Ben Mee tackle, though.

1 Like