Also, no club will part with a good player halfway through their own season.
1 Like
Arenāt lots of clubs (particularly in France) very short of money meaning we might get a CB in cheaper than a usual year? Really want to win it again this year so the team can have a double celebration bus tour around Liverpool when hopefully weāll be able to attend! CL and FA Cup win as well this year would be appreciated please! 
7 Likes
Works in theory but in reality it wouldnāt be that expensive buying a CB that would be an improvement on Phillips who, at various times, is currently somewhere between our 2nd and 4th choice CB. Williams has more potential than Phillips but yet again an upgrade on his current ability levels is not that expensive either. Patience, I think someone is coming itāll just be a particularly difficult time to negotiate at the moment. Thereās no point arguing too hard about why it wonāt happen when it may well still happen. Even Klopp kind of admits we are trying.
8 Likes
Covid 19 will have cost us over Ā£100m I reckon. Thats a good CB right there and a back-up. We really cannot dismiss the impact as you say.
Any major purchase will be financed against the future so even if we buy everyone will be bitvhing and moaning in the summer 
3 Likes
Coronavirus and the new entry requirements following Brexit do significantly further complicate what is already a very difficult window in which to bring in the right players.
5 Likes
Sure, but when you are skint, you are skint. No way around it.
Edit: I donāt want to pretend that we are truly skint. Thanks to the massive TV deals, thereās still enough to pay the astronomical player wages (hopefully). But thereās just no way that the club will lay out Ā£ 50 millions on a new player right now, just to fill a temporary gap.
2 Likes
Itās not a temporary gap. Matip will never play a full season, and the juryās out on Gomez. That leaves us with VVD and a converted midfielder. Itās generally accepted that top teams need four first team centre backs. Even without this hideous injury wave we needed a new CB.
14 Likes
Who will turn thirty in July and isnāt guaranteed to make a full recovery from the injury anyway.
Thereās a possibility he wonāt be the same player when he does return, not because of his age necessarily (people donāt just fall of a cliff once they hit 30) but due to the nature of the damage. His age means that we may well need to look for his long-term successor.
10 Likes
Why would it have to be anywhere near that?
4 Likes
Because a lesser sum brings you a lesser player, or maybe a good youngster who isnāt ready yet to play week in week out.
1 Like
1 Like
Not with our recruitment. There are plenty of good, young, CBs who seem like they could fit our playing requirements quite well that probably wouldnāt cost half that. In fact the only CBs who would are very high profile ones and mostly either wouldnāt fit our playing style, pass the attitude test or have worrying injury records.
2 Likes
Any ideas?
1 Like
Iām not sure there are actually. There seems to be a real dearth of quality centre backs out there, and even the good ones are shite, if you know what I mean. Weāve got the best one, and heās miles ahead of anyone else.
So I think the question the club have to answer is whether there is anyone who presents a better option than Williams and Koumetio, Hendo if necessary, to the extent that itās worth spending a serious lump of money in them.
In a lot of ways, this is a real test of the clubs transfer operation. We know they like to plan long term, and we know they will stick to the plan come what may. At what point does a crisis become such a crisis that you have to go out try and sort it with a short term fix. They do not spend money on solutions that are not perfect.
Does the club dig in and get through the rest of the season with Matipās limited availability, Hendo filling in, and using the kids. Or do we go off plan and buy the best of whatās available?
2 Likes
I think itās lazy to say that. Was Robertson a proven quality LB? Gini CM? Matip CB? Hell even VvD, Mane and Salah had question marks over them. We are turning into snobs and unless there is a player equal to what we have now we arenāt interested. But nearly our whole squad would have been rejected on their pre-LFC standing based on that. Their are loads of young CBs out there that are better CBs than Phillips, Williams and Henderson. If we pick one well matched to our style of football it could be a monster of a signing. Or at worst a Klavan or Shaqiri level signing that gets us out of some temporary shit till we can address it better in the future.
8 Likes
I asked already: any ideas? So for you, looking at the above, itās rather a youngish CB with a high ceiling than a confirmed superstar?
This club has one of the worldās best scouting system. So, if they donāt move for one of these alleged young CBs this month, it will mean one of two options:
- there are no young CBs deemed significantly better than the likes of Phillips, Williams, Koumetio.
- there are, but they would be too expensive for our current financial state, and thatās it.
I guess weāll see what happens before the end of this month, eh?
2 Likes
When you say Virgil had question marks you lose all ability to argue anythingā¦ Sorry.
We are heading into a country wide lock downā¦ Football might get put on holdā¦ Fans still not back in stadiumsā¦ Revenue utterly gutted for everyoneā¦
And youāre bemoaning signings, fuck me, perspective.
1 Like
Cancel the transfer window. Play a game everyday. Last man standing wins the league.
3 Likes
Militao would be great. An aggressive Brazilian defender with good enough size. If we donāt get Botman, Militao would top the list for me. Heās more experienced too at age 22. Botman will probably be cheaper but not as ready for the Prem as Militao imo.
2 Likes